TL;DR

Notion is powerful but problematic. Great for teams who need a customizable workspace. Frustrating for anyone who just wants fast, simple note-taking.

  • Use it if: You need team collaboration + complex databases + are willing to spend weeks learning it
  • Skip it if: You want speed, simple notes, or don't need collaboration
  • Try instead: Obsidian (personal notes), Todoist (tasks), or Coda (team docs)

Our rating: 4/5 — Powerful, but the performance issues and complexity hold it back.

The Honest Truth About Notion

Notion is one of those tools that people either love obsessively or abandon after a few frustrated months. There's not much in between.

I've been using it daily for over two years. I've built complex team workspaces with it. I've also rage-quit it multiple times when it took 10 seconds to load a simple page.

Here's what you actually need to know.

What Notion Gets Right

All-in-One Flexibility

Notion genuinely can replace multiple tools: notes, wikis, project management, databases, simple CRMs, content calendars. The flexibility is real. You can build almost anything with blocks, databases, and relations.

Team Collaboration

Real-time collaboration works well. Comments, mentions, shared workspaces—it's all smooth. If you need a team knowledge base or project hub, Notion handles this better than most alternatives.

Database Power

The database features are genuinely impressive. Linked databases, rollups, relations, multiple views (table, kanban, calendar, gallery). For complex workflows, this is where Notion shines.

What Notion Gets Wrong

It's Slow. Really Slow.

This is the #1 complaint across every forum and community. Notion is not a fast app.

If you're used to apps like Obsidian, Apple Notes, or even Google Docs, Notion will feel frustratingly slow.

Workaround: Use the desktop app (about 50% faster than web). Reduce visible properties in databases. Avoid giant pages.

The Learning Curve Is Real

People on Reddit report it taking up to a year to fully learn Notion. That's not a typo.

The interface has too many options. Simple tasks feel complicated. You'll spend more time organizing your organization system than actually working.

One user put it perfectly: Notion is "a monster system that consumes more time than it saves for basic personal use."

Overkill for Simple Use Cases

If you just want to:

...Notion is way too much. You'll spend more time fighting the tool than using it. Apple Notes, Obsidian, or even a plain text file would serve you better.

The AI Push

Notion has been aggressively pushing their AI features. Some users hate this—especially the fact that it's hard to fully disable, even on Enterprise plans. If you just want a workspace without AI upsells, this gets annoying.

Notion vs The Alternatives

Notion vs Obsidian

Factor Notion Obsidian
Best for Team collaboration Personal knowledge management
Speed Slow (web-based) Fast (local files)
Data ownership On Notion's servers Local Markdown files you own
Offline Limited Full offline access
Collaboration Excellent Basic (requires sync setup)
Learning curve Steep Moderate

The verdict: Obsidian wins for personal use, privacy, and speed. Notion wins for teams.

Notion vs Coda

Coda is Notion's closest competitor for team workspaces. It has similar database features but with more powerful formulas and automations. If you outgrow Notion's capabilities, Coda is worth considering.

Who Should Use Notion

Good Fit

  • Teams needing a shared workspace
  • Complex project management
  • Content teams with editorial calendars
  • People who enjoy building systems
  • Those willing to invest time learning

Bad Fit

  • Simple note-taking needs
  • Personal task management
  • Anyone who values speed
  • People who want things to "just work"
  • Privacy-conscious users

Pricing

The free plan is usable for personal use, but you'll hit limits quickly on a team.

The Bottom Line

Our Verdict: 4/5

Notion is genuinely powerful for the right use case: teams who need a flexible, collaborative workspace and are willing to invest time building it out.

But it's not the right choice for everyone. If you want speed, simplicity, or primarily personal use—look elsewhere. The performance issues and complexity tax are real.

Try it free before committing. Give it 2-3 weeks of real use. You'll know quickly whether it fits your brain or frustrates it.